Hugo Liebel was cited for violating the Animal Welfare Act numerous times over the decades on multiple accounts, including but not limited to:
In 2011, the United States Department of Agriculture brought 33 formal charges against Nosey’s owner, which could have resulted in her confiscation. Instead, in a settlement agreement reached in 2013, Liebel has assessed a civil penalty of $7,500 and ordered to stop violating the AWA. Despite this agreement, Liebel has been cited at least four additional times for failing to protect Nosey or other animals in his care as well as the public with whom they come in contact.
After working in the circus for three decades, Nosey was spotted in November, 2017, standing in her own waste, chained, beside the road in Lawrence County, Alabama. Some quick-witted advocates contacted Administrators of Save Nosey Now to ask for guidance. Subsequently, Nosey was seized by an Animal Control Officer in that County. She was immediately transferred to The Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee where she was medically and psychologically evaluated and where she can be an independent elephant. A bench trial for her custody was held where a very conscientious Assistant District Attorney took on her abusive owners. Evidence of the cruelty she had endured her whole life was presented. After several weeks of careful deliberation, the Judge ordered Nosey to the custody of the Animal Control Officer who made the decision to keep Nosey at the Sanctuary. Nosey’s former abusers were charged with animal cruelty, but they did appeal the Judge’s order. In December 2020, The Elephant Sanctuary in Tennessee was awarded permanent custody of Nosey by the court in Alabama. Nosey has EARNED her retirement in a true elephant sanctuary, where she is now living in peace. No more rides, no more performances, no more bull hooks!